Robert William Goodrich, "The Political Selection of Ideology [a review of: Richard Weikart, Socialist Darwinism: Evolution in German Socialist Thought from Marx to Bernstein, International Scholars Publications, Bethesda, Md. 1998]" (2001)
H-NET BOOK REVIEW, published by H-Ideas (March, 2001); http://h-net.msu.edu/cgi-bin/logbrowse.pl?trx=vx&list=h-german&month=0103&week=d&msg=YN6k/gk8ZOdzqXT1WUcMuA&user=&pw=
H-NET BOOK REVIEW
Published by H-Ideas (March, 2001)
Richard Weikart. Socialist Darwinism: Evolution in German Socialist Thought
from Marx to Bernstein. Bethesda, Md: International Scholars Publications,
1998. x + 257 pp. Notes, bibliography, index. $74.95 (cloth), ISBN
1-57308-290-8.
Reviewed by Robert William Goodrich, Department of Philosophy, Religion,
and History, Augustana College.
The Political Selection of Ideology
In the nineteenth century, Karl Marx and Charles Darwin unleashed a torrent
of scientific and social controversy that has yet to recede fully. Both
men's theories challenged the political, social, scientific, and moral
ordering of society. Yet, neither man could control his legacy. Darwin's
ideas were bastardized and popularly misunderstood as Social Darwinism,
while the ever-sensitive Marx was so distraught over the corruption of his
ideas that he once commented that he was not a Marxist. Indeed, their fates
were intertwined in more ways than one, for social theorists looked to
science for legitimacy. Socialist theoreticians in particular prided
themselves on their broad reading and scientific methodology.
Exploring just one overlap of scientific and social theory, Richard Weikart
presents a rich intellectual history of prominent German socialist
theorists' reception of Darwinism in the nineteenth century. With each
chapter organized around an individual theoretician, Weikart's work wades
through an impressive array of primary source material including published
books, articles, speech manuscripts, and some previously unknown
correspondences to reveal a heterogeneous, inconsistent, and dynamic
relationship between German socialists and contemporary science. Indeed,
Weikart's main thesis claims, "The German socialists' reception of
evolutionary theory illustrates the mutual interpretation of scientific and
social thought" and "Social theory dictated the extent to which Darwinism
was accepted in socialist circles" (pp. 2-3).
First and foremost, Weikart sets out to explore the "interconnectedness of
scientific and social thought" (p. 223), specifically the impact of
Darwinism on socialist revisionism. Weikart asks, did the gradualist
evolution in Darwin's theory of nature inform an evolutionary view of
socialism in opposition to a revolutionary theory? Alongside this central
theme, Weikart includes a chapter on "The Role of Biologists" and engages
in brief forays into Darwinism's effect on socialism's view of eugenics,
race, and religion, all of which provide tantalizing introductions into the
breadth of evolutionary and Social Darwinistic thought at all levels of
socialist theory -- a phenomenon many prefer to relegate to the German Right.
By the phrase "socialist Darwinism," Weikart consciously distances the
integration of Darwinism into socialist thought from the more widely used
Social Darwinism. And here is one of Weikart's consistently illuminated
arguments -- that leading socialists did not accept the direct application
of Darwinism to society; rather, based on the uniqueness of man, they
separated Darwin's natural theory from socialist social theory. Indeed, the
inability to reconcile the two led many leaders to embrace non-Darwinian
evolutionary theories. For this argument, Weikart presents a complex
constellation of ideologies: Marxist (Marx, Engels, Bebel, Bernstein, and a
mature Kautsky) and non-Marxist (Lange, Buechner, Dodel, the young Kautsky)
socialism; Darwinian and non-Darwinian (especially Tremaux and Lamarck)
evolutionary theory; and non-socialist proponents and opponents of various
strands of evolutionary theory. In this confusing intellectual maelstrom,
it is not surprising, as Weikart reveals, that Marxists, including Marx,
proved inconsistent.
Weikart avoids the temptation of a theoretical teleology that culminated in
the abandonment of revolutionary principles first in the war crisis of 1914
and later in the Bad Godesberg Program of 1959. Instead, Weikart reveals
the "ambiguous relationship" (p. 221) of German socialism to Darwinism. The
inconsistent and even contradictory approach to the increasingly popular
and popularized theories of natural selection appears on every page. The
rich correspondence between intellectual and political leaders exposes the
tension and uncertainty towards Darwinism that lay beneath the common
perception of a homogeneously positive reception by socialists.
The men (and there are only men) whose ideas fill the pages are all
well-known to any historian of the nineteenth century: Karl Marx, Friedrich
Engels, Friedrich Albert Lange, Ludwig Buechner, August Bebel, Karl
Kautsky, and Eduard Bernstein. And one might initially be inclined to think
that Weikart travels a well-worn path. Weikart's strength, however, is to
bring new sources and a problematized perspective. Yet he never dares to
venture beyond the viewpoints of these giants. While the study is about
reception, Weikart includes only the lofty peaks of the socialist
movements. Admittedly, he defines his subject as the "leading theorists and
propagandists" (p. 8), but even here, he has excluded important socialists
such as Lassalle with the justification that Darwinism was not
"particularly significant in their thought" (p. 8).
Yet Lassalle was more widely read by rank-and-file socialists than either
Marx or Engels. Does this not make his disinterest in Darwin of interest?
Also, where, as in Chapter V, "August Bebel's Popularization of Evolution,"
the promise of a broader perspective emerges, this use of "popularization"
is understood as elite propaganda rather than popular reception. At no
point do the rank and file Social Democrats, the Free Trade Unionists, the
members of ancillary organizations, or the broader circles of non-joining
sympathizers and family members enter the discussion. Bebel's goal may
clearly have been to inculcate a harmonious synthesis of a non-Darwinian
evolutionary theory with Marxism, but the reader ultimately has no sense of
the success of this effort.
This is disappointing. German socialism was a mass movement with multiple
potentialities and counter-currents expressed by those who identified to
varying degrees with socialism and often understood Marxism and Darwinism
in heterodox ways. The role of Darwin's Descent on Kautsky's conversion to
materialism and ultimately socialism found similar parallels among everyday
workers, many of whom never made the transformation to Kautsky's orthodox
Marxism. Indeed, Alfred Kelly, who provides the foreword to the book, has
shown in his collection of working-class autobiographies that socialist
workers eagerly read evolutionary theory but often espoused Social
Darwinist ideas without sensing any contradiction with the Marxist Erfurt
Program.
At times, Weikart's exclusive focus on elites leads to paradoxical
conclusions. For example, Weikart convincingly displays that Bebel and
post-Marx leaders of the SPD drew upon practical experience and multiple
ideological sources rather than Darwin to inform their increasingly
evolutionary approach to social revolution. But he dismisses the influence
of evolutionary theory as "making no inroads" into their ideas (p. 151).
Here, the distance of Weikart's study from popular reception blurs the
negotiated (dare I say dialectical) relationship between theoreticians and
their social/intellectual context. While Weikart clearly situates Marx and
nineteenth-century biologists as products of their time, deeply infused
with prevailing attitudes, he would have the reader minimize this same
contextual structuring inside socialist circles a few decades later.
In the end, however, Weikart provides a methodically written, cogently
argued, and impressively documented intellectual history. He shatters two
dominant myths: that Marxists applied Darwinism directly to social theory
and that "the introduction of evolutionary biological ideas into socialist
theory in the late nineteenth century stripped Marxism of its revolutionary
edge by replacing dialectical materialism and praxis with mechanical
materialism, and by fostering gradualism" (p. 149). While this reviewer
would have enjoyed an expanded discussion of the ultimate significance of
this topic by including the reception and thus broader significance of
these ideas among regular Germans, both socialist and non-socialist, as an
intellectual history Socialist Darwinism brings a freshly problematized
analysis to an important chapter of socialist and indeed social
intellectual history.
Library of Congress call number: HX273 .W514 1998
Subjects:
Socialism--Germany--History
Socialists--Germany
Social Darwinism--Germany
Evolution (Biology)--Philosophy
Citation: Robert William Goodrich . "Review of Richard Weikart, Socialist
Darwinism: Evolution in German Socialist Thought from Marx to Bernstein,"
H-Ideas, H-Net Reviews, March, 2001. URL:
http://www.h-net.msu.edu/reviews/showrev.cgi?path=4475985369635.
Copyright 2001 by H-Net, all rights reserved. H-Net permits the
redistribution and reprinting of this work for nonprofit, educational
purposes, with full and accurate attribution to the author, web location,
date of publication, originating list, and H-Net: Humanities & Social
Sciences Online. For any other proposed use, contact the Reviews editorial
staff at [email protected].
