Sander Gliboff, "Darwin on Trial Again" [a review of: Richard Weikart. From Darwin to Hitler: Evolutionary Ethics, Eugenics, and Racism in Germany] (2004)

H-NET Online, Published by: H-German (September, 2004); http://h-net.msu.edu/cgi-bin/logbrowse.pl?trx=vx&list=h-disability&month=0501&week=c&msg=9uaEAlKgwmCPgfwkDg9UbA&user=&pw=

Richard Weikart. From Darwin to Hitler: Evolutionary Ethics, Eugenics,
and Racism in Germany. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2004. xi + 312 pp.
Illustrations, notes, bibliography, index. $59.95 (cloth), ISBN
1-403-96502-1.

Reviewed by: Sander Gliboff, Department of History and Philosophy of
Science, Indiana University.

Published by: H-German (September, 2004)

Darwin on Trial Again

The American creationist movement has been waging war against Darwin
and modern science for decades, but their strategy is evolving. Instead
of pitting only the Bible against the biology, they are cultivating
their credentials in a variety of academic disciplines and attacking
from many new directions. On the history front, Richard Weikart's book
appropriates the Holocaust and indeed the entire course of Western
civilization for the creationist side, as it traces a decline in
Western morals from the Origin of Species to the origin of National
Socialism. It is being sold at a big discount by the Discovery
Institute, one of several organs of the religious right that is touting
it as an argument against teaching evolution. It may also prove
instrumental in making a case against reforming marriage and legalizing
abortion or assisted suicide, because it includes comparable proposals
among the links between Darwin and Hitler.

According to Weikart, all of these evils have stemmed from Darwinian
"naturalism." Naturalism is the principle that marks the modern
boundary between science and theology or metaphysics. It limits
scientific investigation to the natural realm and disallows
supernatural agencies and divine intervention in scientific
explanations. For example, it might very well please the Creator to
make an object fall with a force that is inversely proportional to the
square of its distance from the center of the earth, but under
naturalism, physicists leave that Creator out of the equations that
describe and explain gravitation. Similarly, biologists do not invoke
the Creator in their work, either.

Among modern creationists, Phillip Johnson first made an issue of
biologists' naturalism in Darwin on Trial (1991), where he raised
legalistic and philosophical objections to the way it banishes God from
the sciences. Here Weikart builds upon Johnson's work with historical
and ethical objections. In particular, he objects to the fact that
Darwin included humanity as part of Nature and treated the human mind
and the moral sense as subjects for biological research. Rather than
investigate Man's immortal soul or the divine foundations of ethics,
Darwin's naturalistic approach took ethics to be a human creation, a
product of the brain and of cultural and biological evolution. That,
says Weikart, undermined traditional Christian values and constituted
the first link in a chain of ideas leading to National Socialism and
the Holocaust.

The book is very well crafted to maintain a scholarly stance and avoid
any blatant evangelizing or explicit political advocacy. It never cites
Johnson or other creationists and it does not identify the author as a
fellow of the Discovery Institute. Skillfully, it deploys the bugbear
of naturalism to draw attention away from anti-Semitism, with its
inconvenient Christian connections, as well as from any other
intellectual, political, social, cultural, economic, diplomatic,
military, or technological components of Nazism or factors in Hitler's
success. The result, by scholarly standards, is an overly narrow and
selective history, which makes only cursory use of the extensive
secondary literature on the origins of National Socialism and the
history of Darwinism.[1]

In the first part of the book, titled "Laying new foundations for
ethics," Weikart anchors the Darwinian end of his chain of ideas. He
has Darwin and early Darwinians developing evolutionary systems of
ethics. These systems varied among themselves or allowed for historical
change in ethical norms, hence were relativistic in comparison to
Christianity, which was absolute. Part two, "Devaluing human life,"
ascribes to Darwinians the view that individual human lives are not
sacred, not equal, and may be sacrificed selectively for the sake of
evolutionary progress or other perceived good. Here the chain branches
and links up with eugenics on the one hand and with scientific theories
of racial inequality on the other. Part three, "Eliminating the
'inferior ones,'" connects the theories to practical proposals. On the
eugenics branch: promoting population fitness through marriage reform,
birth control, abortion, infanticide, and euthanasia. On the side of
scientific racism: promoting international and inter-racial struggle,
imperialism, and militarism. Part four, "Impacts," completes the chain
to Hitler, who, Weikart argues, was influenced by both the practical
proposals and the theories of ethics, which he needed for winning
converts to his cause. Hitler and his followers are depicted not as
amoral, but as having embraced the wrong sort of morality, the
naturalistic sort, instead of the one that was engraved in stone. And
that, so to speak, is the moral of Weikart's story: there is no
workable form of morality that is not God-given and absolute. All else
leads to Hitler.

Methodologically, the book is the kind of history of ideas that
connects thinkers and texts by means of conceptual or linguistic
resemblances. There are indeed some thought-provoking connections to be
made here, for as is well known, National Socialism incorporated ideas
about biology, race, struggle, and survival. Less well known may be the
particular scientists and social thinkers in Weikart's study, whose
writings conveyed Darwinian ideas to the twentieth-century German
audience. They developed various naturalistic systems of ethics and
various proposals for racial advancement, some of which were
reprehensible by any reasonable standard, and some of which bore
resemblances to later Nazi ideas.

The method becomes problematic, however, when one tries to argue from
these kinds of resemblances to causal relationships. Is the scientific
causing the political? Influencing it? Converging with it? Being
appropriated and misrepresented by it? Maybe the influences go the
other way, and science is responding to political trends and pressures.
Maybe science and politics are both responding to something else in the
historical context. A good historian of science will have an eye out
for various patterns of give and take among biologists, physicians,
social philosophers, politicians, even theologians, interested segments
of the public, and eventually Hitler. With Weikart, it is a foregone
conclusion that the connections are causes and influences, always
emanating from Darwin.

Weikart goes so far as to assert that "in philosophical terms,
Darwinism was a necessary, but not a sufficient, cause for Nazi
ideology" (p. 9). As the book portrays it, Darwinism's causal role lay
in undermining Christian ethics, which would otherwise have held as the
last bastion against Nazism, no matter how many other causes were
working in Hitler's favor. I suppose this is also the rationalization
for leaving all those other causes out of the book. There is of course
no way to investigate what would have happened without Darwinism, or
even to imagine the modern world without any challenges to pre-modern
Christian doctrines. Perhaps Nazism could have been avoided, as Weikart
asserts. Perhaps it would only have had to appropriate less biological
rhetoric and more of some other sort.

Weikart tries to argue that no ideology as coherent and destructive as
Nazism could ever have developed as long as ethics stood on
unquestioned Christian foundations, which upheld the sanctity of every
individual life. He seems at times to picture a halcyon pre-Darwinian
past, when the absolute theoretical foundations of ethics made a real
difference in practice. However, as Weikart does acknowledge, there
were many ethical lapses before Darwin, too. One might reasonably doubt
whether Western civilization was significantly more corrupt after its
intellectuals took the naturalistic turn, but Weikart does not. He
argues--incredibly, for someone who likes his morals absolute--that
things like racism and slavery were less bad before Darwin, because
Europeans still had Christian values and were moved to send
missionaries to Africa as well as slave traders (pp. 103, 185).

It is dismaying to see such opinions being passed off as results of
scholarly research. The book's few merits only deepen the dismay
because they suggest that Weikart knows better. His book is rich in
primary material, thoroughly documented, and clearly and concisely
written. It features an intriguing and diverse cast of characters,
including biologists like Ernst Haeckel, philosophers like Christian
Ehrenfels, the eugenicists Alfred Ploetz and Wilhelm Schallmayer, the
psychologist August Forel, and the feminist Helene Stoecker.
Unfortunately, Weikart only repeats their most outrageous stances on
ethics and human evolution and omits their criticisms of the
still-Christian (despite Darwin) societies in which they lived. In
short, he does not strive for a contextual understanding of the
selected writers any more than for an explanation of Hitler. They are
only characters in a contrived, cautionary tale against religious
apostasy, Darwinism, and free inquiry into the foundations of ethics.

Note

[1]. Relevant works on the roles of science, medicine, and eugenics in
the history of National Socialism include, e.g.: Henry Friedlander, The
Origins of Nazi Genocide: From Euthanasia to the Final Solution (Chapel
Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1995); Robert N. Proctor,
Racial Hygiene. Medicine under the Nazis (Cambridge, MA: Harvard
University Press, 1988). On important discontinuities between Weimar
eugenics and Nazi extermination: Atina Grossmann, Reforming Sex. The
German Movement for Birth Control and Abortion Reform, 1920-1950 (New
York & Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1995). For an overview of the
history of Darwinism, including discussion of religion and morals, see
Peter J. Bowler, Evolution: The History of an Idea (Berkeley:
University of California Press, 2003). For a more detailed historical
treatment of Darwinian ethics: Robert J. Richards, Darwin and the
Emergence of Evolutionary Theories of Mind and Behavior (Chicago:
University of Chicago Press, 1987).

Citation: Sander Gliboff. "Review of Richard Weikart, From Darwin to
Hitler: Evolutionary Ethics, Eugenics, and Racism in Germany,"
H-German, H-Net Reviews, September, 2004. URL:
http://www.h-net.org/reviews/showrev.cgi?path=37981105462766.

Copyright © 2004 by H-Net, all rights reserved. H-Net permits the
redistribution and reprinting of this work for nonprofit, educational
purposes, with full and accurate attribution to the author, web
location, date of publication, originating list, and H-Net: Humanities
& Social Sciences Online. For any other proposed use, contact the
Reviews editorial staff at [email protected].