Paul Lawrence Farber, A review of: Richard Weikart, From Darwin to Hitler: Evolutionary Ethics, Eugenics, and Racism in Germany (2005)

Journal of the History of Biology 2005, vol. 38, s. 390-391.

Paul Lawrence Farber

Richard Weikart, From Darwin to Hitler: Evolutionary Ethics, Eugenics, and Racism in
Germany
(New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2004), xi + 312 pp., $59.95.
Journal of the History of Biology 2005, vol. 38, s. 390-391.

In an often-cited letter written to Charles Darwin on Christmas Eve Day in 1859, Adam
Sedgwick expressed his concern about the moral implications of Darwin's newly published
book, On the Origin of Species. Sedgwick noted that were it possible to break the link
between natural history and natural theology, humankind would experience a brutalizing
degradation. Since then opponents of the theory of evolution have used this criticism
repeatedly, and it continues to be a central point in contemporary critiques of modern
science, evolutionary biology, and secular worldviews. Once the link with the
sacred/supernatural is broken, all things are permissible (as Dostoyevsky warned). Richard
Weikart presents a variation of this critique of Darwin in his new book, From Darwin to
Hitler. The central argument that informs his narrative is that Darwin's naturalism
devalued human life and made possible the excesses of the Nazi regime.

Like other attempts to tar Darwin with all of the problems of modernity, Weikart's
suffers from conceptual flaws that detract from his book, which contains some interesting
material on the German eugenics movement, popular Darwinism in Germany, and German
evolutionary ethics. Weikart is critical of Daniel Gasman's attempt to link Haeckel and
Nazi ideology, and he notes that all Darwinians were not eugenicists, all eugenicists were
not Darwinians, and all Nazis were not Darwinians. Yet, he insists that the critical moral
breakdown that permitted some German eugenicists to espouse euthanasia, and ultimately
racial extermination, was the Darwinian theory that presented human history in
naturalistic terms, not as part of a divine drama. But it is a very long way from
barnacles to the death camps. Weikart sidesteps the issue that German materialism, as
reflected by Ludwig Büchner (1855), was far more radical and relied more on experimental
physiology than natural history for its scientific legitimacy. Similarly, he
overemphasizes the power of ideas in driving history. Intellectual historians have come to
realize that economic forces, social structures, and political conflicts play key roles in
historical developments.

Although Weikart mentions various individuals outside the German speaking areas, he
doesn't explore the comparative aspects of his story. Evolution and eugenics were also
popular in the United States and Britain, Russia and Scandinavia. That interest, and the
secular forces in those countries, did not lead to the enactment and enforcement of social
policies we associate with the Racial Hygiene movement in Nazi Germany. Why not? And, has
a concept of the sacred been an effective shield against the taking of human life? The
Thirty Year's War was as barbaric an event as Western history has experienced, and
religion was not lacking at the time. Modern history is not lacking in examples of
religiously inspired killing. I suspect that few suicide bombers have Darwin fishes on
their bumpers or in their hearts.

Weikart's book will comfort those who believe that the materialism and naturalism
characteristic of contemporary science need to be rejected in favor of a more religious
perspective, be it Intelligent Design or strict Creationism. It ignores the many syntheses
that have been crafted by deeply religious individuals who have embraced modern science,
and presents a flawed narrative along the lines of "for want of a nail, a kingdom was
lost." The great figures in Western Science, for example Copernicus, Darwin, Einstein,
and Freud, have all been the subject of mythmaking as well as demonizing. Historians of
science spend a lot of time writing and teaching to present a more balanced account.
Weikart's book, unfortunately, is likely to spawn more urban myths about Darwin that
will have to be addressed.