Catherine Candisky, "Evolution Debate Re-Emerges:

Ohio teacher's dissertation under Darwinist attack; "Columbus Dispatch" (Ohio) June 9, 2005 Thursday, Home Final Edition, Pg. 01C.

"Columbus Dispatch" (Ohio) June 9, 2005 Thursday, Home Final Edition; Pg. 01C

EVOLUTION DEBATE RE-EMERGES ;
Doctoral student's work was possibly unethical, OSU professors argue

Catherine Candisky, THE COLUMBUS DISPATCH

A doctoral dissertation, of all things, is the latest lightning rod in the
battle over teaching evolution in Ohio.

Ohio State University is investigating the makeup of a committee set to
review the graduate work of a Hilliard Davidson High School biology
teacher. The panel is stacked with creationists and the research might be
unethical, some OSU faculty members say.

The teacher, Bryan Leonard, helped draft Ohio's plan calling for "critical
analysis of evolution" in high-school science classes. More recently, he
testified before the Kansas Board of Education, which is considering a
similar proposal.

Leonard's defense of his dissertation, required for his doctorate in
science education, was postponed from Monday.

Earle Holland, director of research communications for Ohio State, said the
graduate school is reviewing the dissertation panel to ensure its
membership is qualified and appropriate.

Privacy laws, he said, prevent the university from saying more.

The battle underscores the volatility of debate about the origins and
development of life on Earth, which has erupted before school boards in
Ohio, Kansas and elsewhere.

Educators are wrestling with how best to teach evolution and opposing ideas
such as intelligent design -- the notion that life forms are too complex to
be explained and that a higher power must have been involved.

Critics call intelligent design a thinly veiled version of creationism.
They say it's a belief, not science, and shouldn't be taught in biology class.

In general, dissertation committees are to consist of a student's faculty
adviser, another professor in the student's field of study, a professor in
the department from which the degree is being sought and a representative
of the graduate school.

"There is evidence that Mr. Leonard's dissertation committee has been
improperly constituted and that his research may have involved unethical
human-subject experimentation," three professors wrote Friday in a letter
to Carole Anderson, interim dean of Ohio State's graduate school. The
experimentation it refers to is the instruction of Leonard's high-school
students.

The letter is signed by Brian W. McEnnis, a mathematics professor; Jeffrey
K. McKee, an anthropology professor; and Steve Rissing, an evolution,
ecology and organismal biology professor.

The three have not read Leonard's research but based their comments on
testimony he gave before the Kansas Board of Education last month, McKee said.

The main research questions in Leonard's dissertation are: "When students
are taught the scientific data both supporting and challenging
macroevolution, do they maintain or change their beliefs over time? What
empirical, cognitive and/or social factors influence students' beliefs?"

The critics wrote, "We note a fundamental flaw: There are no valid
scientific data challenging macroevolution. Mr. Leonard has been
misinforming students if he teaches them otherwise. His thesis presents
evidence that he has succeeded in persuading high school students to reject
this fundamental principle of biology. As such, it involves deliberate
miseducation of these students, a practice we regard as unethical."

While Leonard's research concerns the teaching of evolution, no member of
his dissertation committee is a science educator or evolutionary biologist,
the three say.

Leonard declined to comment yesterday. Members of his dissertation
committee either had no comment or didn't return telephone messages.

His faculty adviser is Paul Post, an assistant professor in the College of
Education. Also on the committee are professors Glen R. Needham, an
entomology professor in the College of Biological Sciences, and Robert
DiSilvestro, a professor of human nutrition in the College of Human Ecology.

Jody F. Sjogren, co-founder of Science Excellence for All Ohioans, said
evolutionists appear to be trying to shut down debate because they can't
win and are quick to label anyone who challenges them as religious
fundamentalists. Sjogren's group, formed during the debate before Ohio's
State Board of Education, favors the teaching of intelligent design.

"I think people trying to hamper academic freedom are going to find
themselves swimming upstream against public preference."

But critics make a distinction between academic freedom and academic
responsibility.

"There are some real fine lines in terms of information a researcher can
present," said Lynn Elfner, head of the Ohio Academy of Science.

"By virtue of his testimony in Kansas, he is trying to influence public
policy with research that has not passed muster in graduate school."

[email protected]

Copyright 2005 The Columbus Dispatch