Charles Colson, "Teach the Controversy: The Intelligent Design in Schools" (2005)

BreakPoint with Charles Colson
Commentary #050303 - 03/03/2005
Teach the Controversy: The Intelligent Design in Schools

Are we due for a twenty-first-century version of the Scopes Monkey Trial? That's what a lot of scientists, educators, and reporters seem to believe.

The National Center for Science Education reports that the teaching of evolution is being challenged in seventeen states. These include Kansas, where a decision will soon be made on whether intelligent design should be taught in schools, and Wisconsin, where one school district requires the teaching of the "scientific strengths and weaknesses of evolutionary theory." One Georgia county required a sticker in school science textbooks explaining that evolution is "a theory, not a fact" -- until last month, that is, when a court (wrongly, in my opinion) ruled the stickers unconstitutional.

Many see all of these challenges and debates as nothing less than an all-out assault on science by the great unwashed. The most frequent complaint is that intelligent design is a religious theory, not a scientific one, and as such has no place in a science classroom or textbook. For instance, the executive director of the National Association of Biology Teachers has said, "There is no research to support [intelligent design], and it is clearly religious in that it posits a higher being."

This complaint displays abysmal ignorance. There are peer-reviewed scholarly journals being published which discuss intelligence in the universe's design. Indeed, Einstein himself said there is intelligence in the universe. The number of scientists who believe this is growing, and they study the same evidence that evolutionists do. And by the way, they agree that natural selection takes place -- within a species. What they posit, however, is that the Darwinian theory of origins is not enough to explain the complexity of life and that the appearance of design in nature justifies the belief that nature was designed.

But for many scientists today, science is inseparable from naturalism, and so a challenge to one leads to a challenge to the other. One critic of intelligent design calls it an attack on all of science, which, for him, is necessarily atheistic. But that completely ignores the fact that some of the greatest scientists in history, like Isaac Newton, have believed in an intelligent designer. And their number is growing, including, of all people, the long-time notorious atheist philosopher Antony Flew, who has become convinced there is a God because of evidence presented by advocates of intelligent design.

Now, you need to understand what's at stake here and you need to get the best arguments available. Those who try to participate in this debate without fully understanding the subject can sometimes do more harm than good, by confirming the widespread belief that the anti-Darwinism forces just don't know what they're talking about. We need to argue science against science and teach, not less evolution, but more -- including all the holes in the theory Darwinians try to cover up. (BreakPoint.org has materials and links that will give you a helpful grounding on this issue.)

In fact, there's no good reason why our schools shouldn't be able to teach students about both sides of the controversy. Questioning the weaknesses in the Darwinian theory of evolution doesn't mean you have to bring the Bible into a science classroom. It does mean you have to keep an open mind and study all the available evidence -- scientific evidence, that is. Isn't that what education is all about? Call us here at BreakPoint (1-877-322-5527) so we can help equip you to argue intelligently.

For printer-friendly version, visit http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11909&et=T&s=131333 and simply click on Today's Commentary at the top of the homepage. The printer-friendly link is on the left-hand column.

Copyright (c) 2005 Prison Fellowship THIS IS A RUSH TRANSCRIPT.
THIS COPY MAY NOT BE IN FINAL FORM AND MAY BE UPDATED. "BreakPoint with Chuck Colson" is a daily commentary on news and trends from a Christian perspective. Heard on more than 1000 radio outlets nationwide, BreakPoint transcripts are also available on the Internet. BreakPoint is a production of The Wilberforce Forum, a division of Prison Fellowship: 44180 Riverside Parkway, Lansdowne, VA 20176.

FOR FURTHER READING AND INFORMATION
Today's BreakPoint offer: "Privileged Planet" (available in DVD or VHS) is must viewing for students and educators. This hour-long documentary explores the scientific evidence for intelligent design and purpose in the universe.
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11923&et=T&s=131333

http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11924&et=T&s=131333

"School board to appeal ruling to remove evolution stickers," CNN, 18 January 2005.
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11925&et=T&s=131333

Jon Hurdle, "Politics and religion enter into evolution debate," MSNBC News, 10 February 2005.
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11926&et=T&s=131333

Suzanne Goldenberg, "Religious right fights science for the heart of America," GUARDIAN UNLIMITED, 7 February 2005.
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11927&et=T&s=131333

Michael Behe, "Design for a Living," NEW YORK TIMES, 7 February 2005. (Reprinted by Discovery Institute.)
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11928&et=T&s=131333

Richard Gallagher, "Intelligent Design and Informed Debate," THE SCIENTIST, 28 February 2005.
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11929&et=T&s=131333

BreakPoint Commentary No. 050110, "Weighing the Evidence: An Atheist Abandons Atheism."
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11930&et=T&s=131333

BreakPoint Commentary No. 050118, "Sticker Wars: A Case of the Blind Leading the Rest of Us."
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11931&et=T&s=131333

Phillip E. Johnson, "Intelligent Design, Freedom, and Education," BREAKPOINT WORLDVIEW, May 2003.
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11932&et=T&s=131333

See Chuck Colson's Ten Questions about Origins.
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11933&et=T&s=131333

See BreakPoint's information page on intelligent design and evolution.
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11934&et=T&s=131333

William Dembski, UNCOMMON DISSENT: INTELLECTUALS WHO FIND DARWINISM UNCONVINCING (ISI Books, 2004).
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11935&et=T&s=131333

NOTE: Referral to websites not produced by Prison Fellowship, the Wilberforce Forum, and BreakPoint is for informational purposes only and does not necessarily constitute an endorsement of the sites' content.

NEW ON BREAKPOINT
"Second Sight": "Keeping Love Hot: The Effects of Lawlessness" by T. M. Moore
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11936&et=T&s=131333

RECOMMENDED RESOURCES
"PRIVILEGED PLANET" (available in DVD or VHS) is must viewing for students and educators. This hour-long documentary explores the scientific evidence for intelligent design and purpose in the universe.
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11923&et=T&s=131333

http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11924&et=T&s=131333

Learn more about what intellectuals believe about evolution and intelligent design in the book UNCOMMON DISSENT.
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11935&et=T&s=131333

For books, CDs, videos, and other materials visit the BreakPoint Store.
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11902&et=T&s=131333

BreakPoint to Go! Get BreakPoint delivered to your handheld device or mobile phone.
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11903&et=T&s=131333

SUPPORT BREAKPOINT
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11904&et=T&s=131333

LISTEN TO BREAKPOINT
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11911&et=T&s=131333

ON THE RADIO
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11907&et=T&s=131333

ABOUT BREAKPOINT
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11901&et=T&s=131333

REPRINT INFORMATION
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11906&et=T&s=131333

BREAKPOINT STAFF
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11901&et=T&s=131333

JOB OPPORTUNITIES
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11899&et=T&s=131333

------------

To subscribe to BreakPoint, click below.
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11908&et=T&s=131333

You are receiving this message as a subscriber to BreakPoint's daily newsletter. If you wish to update your profile or change your subscription preferences, please click below.
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Gateway?p=pfm&u=11905&et=T&s=131333

To remove your e-mail address from Prison Fellowship, click below.
http://msg1svc.net/servlet/Unsubscribe?p=pfm&s=131333&c=153&r=2&l=1008